Compass broker associate Jeremy Olsher says seniors who price out selling, downsizing and home equity options early keep control
Aging in place stops being a choice and becomes a trap when a failing roof or a hospital bill forces the decision, according to Jeremy Olsher (pictured top), broker associate and principal of Mizner Residential Group at Compass in Delray Beach, Florida.
Some 88% of US homeowners 55 and older rate aging in place as extremely or very important, rising to 93% among those 75 and older, according to Longbridge Financial’s 2026 Home Equity Confidence Index of 2,021 homeowners.
Independence ranked first among priorities at 90%, ahead of paying for health care (77%), paying off debt (64%) and long-term care (55%).
What happens when the decision is made for them?
Olsher said the survey misses a key point. “The part that doesn’t show up in the survey is what happens when the decision gets made for them,” he told Mortgage Professional America.
He has seen it firsthand. “I’ve sat with sellers in their late seventies who waited for a roof or a hospital bill to force the question,” Olsher said.
By then, he said, “they’re selling on someone else’s timeline, in whatever market happens to be in front of them.” That, in his view, is “the real cost of equity you can’t reach.”
The homeowners who keep their independence longest, he said, “are usually the ones who priced out their options, selling, downsizing, equity release, while all three were still options.”
The difference shows up in the conversation. With all three paths open, the discussion is a side-by-side comparison of costs and timing. With only one left, usually a forced sale, there is nothing to compare.
US existing home sales fell 5.5% in October to their weakest annualized pace in 16 years. Innovative Mortgage Brokers originator Yury Shraybman says buyers should focus on manageable payments and explore loan structuring options https://t.co/oj19zy05Oc
— Mortgage Professional America Magazine (@MPAMagazineUS) November 13, 2026
How can brokers keep home equity options open?
Senior home equity reached a record $14.92 trillion in the first quarter of 2026, according to the Reverse Mortgage Market Index from the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association (NRMLA) and RiskSpan, but access is uneven.
Steve Irwin, NRMLA’s president, said nearly 40% of home equity line of credit applicants older than 65 are being rejected.
Irwin said retirees increasingly use reverse mortgages “to create a standby line of credit to access in times when the markets may be down,” as he explained in an interview about record senior home equity and reverse mortgage brokers.
Property type matters for clients weighing a downsize. Florida Realtors data show the statewide median single-family price rose 2.2% year over year in October to $420,000, while the condo-townhouse median fell 3.3% to $290,000.
“Housing isn’t one uniform market,” Olsher said. Buyers, sellers and lenders need to “look at the specific property type and local market rather than rely on national headlines,” he said.
Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.