Condo reserve hike faces pushback as groups press FHFA for delay

Five housing and lending associations want more time before stricter HOA funding rules hit Fannie and Freddie condo loans

Condo reserve hike faces pushback as groups press FHFA for delay

A coalition of five housing, mortgage and community association groups wants the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) to delay a tougher condo reserve requirement for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans, warning that it could push sound buildings out of conventional financing.

In a Nov. 19 letter to FHFA Director William J. Pulte, the Community Associations Institute (CAI), the Community Association Roundtable, the Community Home Lenders of America (CHLA), the Housing Policy Council and the National Association of Mortgage Brokers (NAMB) asked for a one-year postponement, from Jan. 4, 2027, to Jan. 4, 2028.

The rule raises the share of an association’s annual budgeted assessment income set aside for reserves from 10% to 15%.

“We encourage FHFA to use the additional implementation period to evaluate the projected impact of the increased reserve requirement on condominium project eligibility rates, mortgage credit availability, borrower affordability, and refinance opportunities across project types and markets,” the groups wrote.

What the condo reserve increase means for borrowers

Fannie Mae puts the average added cost at $13 to $14 per unit each month. The coalition’s own model shows how that can climb. A 100-unit association charging $500 in monthly dues would see its annual reserve contribution rise from $60,000 to $90,000, or about $25 more per unit a month.

“Higher assessments also affect mortgage qualification because lenders must account for condominium association dues when evaluating a borrower’s monthly housing expenses and debt-to-income ratio,” the letter said.

“Even relatively modest increases can affect the purchasing power of borrowers who are already close to qualifying limits.” That ratio is the share of gross monthly income going to debt payments.

Brokers brace for condo projects to lose agency eligibility

“We are particularly concerned that the industry could see an increase in condominium projects that fall outside conventional financing eligibility, even where the underlying properties are fundamentally sound and associations are taking responsible steps to address their long-term maintenance needs,” the coalition wrote.

Non-QM lenders, which have picked up condo borrowers squeezed out of agency programs, see the same risk.

“The reserve requirement for the HOA goes from 10% to 15%,” Tom Davis, chief sales officer at Deephaven Mortgage, said in MPA’s interview on January’s condo deadline.

“So we’re talking about a 50% increase on the reserve allocation. If these HOAs are not reserving for the adequate amount, those projects are not going to qualify for agency financing.”

Kimber White, a Florida broker who was NAMB president when he criticized the FHFA’s condo rule rollout in March, framed the stakes around entry-level buyers.

“It’s the first-time buyer who can afford to get in with three, five, 10% down and get into a starter,” he said.

The coalition stressed it is not opposing stronger reserves.

“Importantly, our request is not an objection to the objective of responsible reserve funding,” the letter said. The groups also asked to meet with Pulte and his staff.

Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.