April sentiment drop underscores how fragile the new‑home recovery remains
Builder confidence in the market for newly built single‑family homes fell in April, undercutting hopes that the spring selling season would steady sentiment after a tentative March uptick.
The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI) dropped four points to 34. That's below economists’ expectations for 37 and down from 38 in March – marking its lowest level since September 2025.
The setback came after three straight months in which the index hovered in the high‑30s, with NAHB data pointing to a market still driven by incentives and tight buyer budgets rather than a decisive turn in demand.
Readings remained below the 50 breakeven line throughout 2025 and into 2026, signaling that more builders viewed conditions as poor than good.
Economic and geopolitical jitters weighed on confidence
“Builder sentiment has fallen back in spring as buyers face ongoing elevated interest rates and growing economic uncertainty,” NAHB chairman Bill Owens, a home builder and remodeler from Worthington, Ohio, said.
“The year started with hopes for housing momentum growth, but risks with respect to the Iran war, energy costs, and declines for consumer confidence have slowed the market.”
Some analysts have characterized the broader US housing sector as being in a deep recession, linking the latest drop in sentiment to higher rates following the Iran conflict.
Costs, incentives and pricing power under pressure
“With oil prices higher in the U.S., 62% of builders reported suppliers have increased building material costs due to higher fuel prices, including gas and diesel,” NAHB chief economist Robert Dietz said.
“Energy costs make up approximately 4% of residential construction material input and service costs. With near‑term economic risks elevated, 70% of builders reported challenges pricing homes given uncertainty about material costs.”
The April survey also showed that 36% of builders cut prices, down slightly from 37% in March, with an average reduction of 5% versus 6% the prior month.
The share using sales incentives stood at 60%, down from 64% in March, but it remained at or above 60% for the 13th straight month – in line with earlier NAHB readings that highlighted widespread discounting even when headline sentiment nudged higher.
Index stayed negative across regions
The HMI, which polled roughly 900 builders on current sales, six‑month sales expectations and buyer traffic, continued to signal broad‑based caution.
In April, the index for current sales fell four points to 37, future sales slid seven points to 42 and buyer traffic dropped three points to 22.
Regionally, three‑month moving averages showed the Northeast at 42, the Midwest at 41, the South flat at 35 and the West at 29.
Taken together, the April pullback suggests that even as mortgage rates edged off late‑2025 peaks and some forecasters spoke of “cautious optimism” for 2026, builders still entered the heart of the selling season constrained by affordability pressures, volatile input costs and unresolved geopolitical risk.
Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.
