Inventory-heavy markets put leverage back in buyers’ hands, if they can afford to use it
Homebuyers in much of the country had the upper hand in early spring 2026, as a surge in listings and retreating demand pushed 38 of the nation’s largest metros into buyer’s market territory.
According to new Redfin data, nationally, sellers outnumbered buyers by about 43% in March, just shy of the widest gap since records began in 2013.
The imbalance reflected a market where roughly 1.99 million would-be sellers faced only 1.39 million active buyers, Redfin estimated, with buyers’ markets far outnumbering the five metros where conditions still favored sellers.
Miami, Nashville, Austin, San Antonio and Las Vegas ranked as the strongest buyer’s markets, each with at least twice as many sellers as buyers. Miami posted roughly 148% more sellers than buyers, followed by Nashville at 119%, Austin at 112%, San Antonio at 109% and Las Vegas at 101%.
Only five metros still favored sellers: Newark, N.J., where there were about 30% fewer sellers than buyers, along with Nassau County, N.Y., Montgomery County, Pa., Milwaukee and New Brunswick, N.J.
Across those markets, prices rose about 4.8% year over year in March, compared with 1.6% growth in the 38 buyer’s markets.
Buyers became choosier as sales slowed
For agents on the ground, the statistical shift has already shown up in client behavior.
“High property taxes, rising insurance costs and fears about job security are making homebuyers very selective,” said Barb Cooper, a Redfin Premier agent in Austin, where sellers outnumbered buyers by more than 100%.
“The buyers who are in the market want turnkey homes in every sense, and they can afford to wait without compromising because we have tons of inventory,” she said.
Redfin’s economics team described the same pattern nationwide. “High housing costs and rising inventory have made homebuyers more selective,” said Chen Zhao, head of economics research at Redfin, in a recent analysis of contract cancellations that tied rising fallout rates to buyers’ expanding options.
Yet this was not a boom. Existing home sales fell 3.6% in March to an annual pace of about 3.98 million, according to the National Association of Realtors, even as inventory ticked up to 1.36 million units.
Sun Belt leverage met stubborn affordability
The sharpest buyer power clustered in the Sun Belt, where pandemic-era migration and aggressive building left metros like Miami and Houston with bloated for-sale inventories relative to a shrinking pool of qualified borrowers.
Redfin’s methodology, which defined buyer’s markets as areas with at least 10% more sellers than buyers, indicated that leverage tended to show up in slower price growth: across March’s 38 buyer’s markets, prices rose roughly 2% year over year, compared with nearly 5% in the five seller’s markets.
Mortgage pros who watched this shift develop said the leverage story still hinged on financing. Lower rates in markets such as Las Vegas briefly drew clients “off the fence,” as one loan officer previously put it, but that many prospective borrowers remained constrained by debt-to-income tests and down payment gaps.
Meanwhile, brokers and lenders described buyers quick to walk if inspections uncovered issues or sellers balked at concessions, echoing Redfin’s findings that more inventory emboldened borrowers to renegotiate or walk away.
What it means for lenders and brokers
For originators, a market with more sellers than buyers does not automatically translate into higher volume. Redfin’s own numbers showed that home prices in seller’s markets still rose faster than in buyer’s markets, while NAR’s data pointed to sluggish overall sales and a still-limited national supply by historic standards.
That leaves mortgage professionals threading a narrow path: coaching well-qualified clients to use their new leverage on price cuts, rate buydowns and repair credits, while acknowledging that many households remain priced out despite the apparent shift in power.
Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.
